The true cost of choosing the property management company that charges the lowest fees

by Carrie Bryant on May 06, 2026
Article appears under: iRentProperty, Property Management

---

As Business Development Manager for iRentProperty, one of the most common questions I get asked is:

“Can you match the cheaper agency’s price?”

My response is always the same. I’m happy to discuss pricing for clients with multiple properties—but I also ask:

“Why would you trust your most expensive asset to the cheapest bidder?”

In my experience, choosing the cheapest option rarely delivers the best outcome. Whether it’s 
supermarket purchases or budget footwear (yes, I own a pair of knock-off Crocs—but only for camping!), cheaper often ends up costing more in the long run.

Property management is no different.

Below are real examples of how going beyond the basics has delivered stronger returns for our client's outcomes that are unlikely to be achieved through a cut-price service.

Proactive letting: You get what you pay for

We often hear: “The other company doesn’t charge a letting fee.”

But this raises an important question—what’s their incentive to go the extra mile?

•          Who is funding thorough background checks?
•          Who is motivated to run additional viewings to secure the best tenant?
•          Who is investing the time to prepare a comprehensive, legally robust tenancy
•          agreement?

Tenant selection and documentation are critical. This is not where shortcuts should be taken.

Takeaway: Discounted fees often mean reduced service. And when it comes to protecting your investment, cutting corners can be costly.

Strategic thinking that comes from an experienced fellow investor

A good tip for investors when they purchase a property is to include clauses in their Sale and Purchase Agreement that maximises the chance of them having a tenant move in right after settlement.
 
This might include the use of marketing shots and access for open homes through the settlement period, plus due diligence around healthy home compliance. This means we can start marketing the property before settlement and potentially have tenants ready to move in the very next day for immediate income.
 
If this strategic process isn’t followed, we recommend budgeting for a 4–6-week vacancy period from the day of settlement to allow for advertising, open homes, and for the incoming tenant to serve their 21-day notice for their current tenant.

Furthermore, we have several tips and tricks to encourage successful tenanting, from the way we shoulder-tap prospective tenants to running our open homes at times that we know will work best for the working population.

Takeaway: Choosing a company with a 6.5% fee instead of 8.5% might save around $13 per week. However, if that same company doesn’t think strategically, delays marketing until after settlement and isn’t proactive in running viewings, you could lose $3,900 in missed rent.

Suddenly, the “cheaper” option doesn’t look so affordable.

Planning my work hours to work for YOU

Property management is a reactive industry. Opportunities don’t always happen between 9–5. 

Late one Friday afternoon, we had excellent tenants ready to move in immediately—but only if we could complete everything, including the tenancy agreement and ingoing inspection, ready for move-in the very next day - the Saturday of a long weekend. 

While many agencies restrict weekend work to emergencies only, we made it happen. The result? A big ‘rented’ sign on the fence, happy tenants and happy clients. 

Takeaway: Smaller Owner-Operated companies may cost more than the bigger franchises, but come with responsiveness and flexibility that directly impacts your returns.

Not taking the easy option

At a different property, I’d just completed the ingoing inspection for a tenancy and noted that at the pre-settlement inspection conducted by the Auckland owner, nobody had picked up that the extractor fans were dripping grease onto the bench, and a pile of rubbish was left in the shed. Plus, in the move out, the net curtains had been washed but poorly hung.

With tenants moving in within the next few days, a quick and easy solution for many property managers would be to call a cleaning company and a handyman to remove the rubbish. Most suppliers won’t get out of bed for less than $125, meaning the owner could have been faced with a $250 bill plus dump fees and materials. Add in a maintenance fee, and this is quickly becoming a decent-sized bill. 

Luckily, with a property management company that goes the extra mile:

•   We carry basic materials such as curtain hooks and draft-stopping tape in our cars
•   I went the extra mile and took the extractor fan grills home to go through my dishwasher
•   I took them back the day before bin day, putting the rubbish in the bin and taking it out to the side  of the road for collection

Cost to owner: $0
Price of client satisfaction to me: $Priceless!

Learning: Service that goes the extra mile doesn’t come with trusting your most expensive assets to the cheapest bidder. You’ll often end up paying more in the long run.

Final Thoughts: What Are You Really Paying For?

When comparing property management companies, it’s easy to focus on fees. But the real question should be:

What value are you getting in return?
At iRentProperty, we don’t aim to be the cheapest—we aim to deliver the best outcomes.
That means:

•         Minimising vacancy
•         Securing high-quality tenants
•         Protecting your asset
•         Maximising your return

Because when your property is managed well, the difference isn’t just a few dollars a week—it’s thousands over the life of your investment.

How We Can Help

If you’re reviewing your current property management or considering your options, we’re happy to have a no-obligation conversation about how we can improve your results.

Get in touch with the iRentProperty team today and experience the difference that proactive, investor-focused management can make.

---